Fisherman's Cup Rules 2015/16


1.1 The competition will be known as the Devon Under 16 League (hereafter referred to as “the league”), and shall be subject to the direction and control of the Devon RFU acting through The Fisherman’s Cup Sub-Committee.

1.2 The competition will be administered by an appointed person, who is responsible for the day-to-day running on behalf of the Devon RFU.

1.3 By entering the competition, Clubs agree to abide by these regulations.

1.4 The Fisherman’s Cup sub-committee will adjudicate on matters relating to the competition. Their decisions are binding on teams entered into the league. Teams are able to appeal on matters of administration of the league to the Devon RFU Competitions Sub-Committee (see Section 10). Any appeal must be in writing, and come from either of the Junior Section Chairman or Secretary supported by the Club Chairman where possible.

1.5 The Devon RFU Competitions Sub-Committee has full powers of adjudicating on all matters relating to the competition and their decisions shall be final.

1.6 The 1st phase (pre Christmas) will be based on three district leagues based in the North and East, Central and South East, South West of the County. (NB: teams will be allocated by the Sub-Committee, and may not necessarily be put into the district league that appears the most obvious, depending on the numbers of teams entering the competition and the need to balance the numbers in each district). The teams will play each other on a home OR away basis with the fixtures to be completed by mid December. Teams will only play the opposition once in this round which is determine from a draw pre-season by the Sub-Committee. On completion of the fixtures, the clubs will then be seeded into new Merit Tables, again, depending on the number of teams, for example:

  1. The top two teams will form the Fishermans Cup League.

  2. The teams finishing in 3rd and 4th places will form the Fishermans Shield League

  3. The teams finishing in 5th, 6th and/or 7th places will form the Fishermans Plate League

  4. A fourth level maybe employed when team numbers are sufficient with the teams finishing in 7th and 8th places.

1.7 In the seeded leagues (2nd phase), the teams that have already played each other in the 1st phase play at the opposite location of the first phase, i.e. home in first phase becomes away in 2nd phase. No points are carried forward for the second phase.

1.8 At the end of the 2nd phase, the top 2 teams in each league will play in a Final for their respective trophy. All of the finals will be held on one day, at Brixham RFC, home of the competition sponsors, normally on the first Sunday in May (May 1st for 2016). Kick off times will be announced nearer the time.

1.9 Teams who were not entered in the first phase of the competition may enter the bottom level league at the start of the second phase after permission has been obtained from the League Sub-Committee. 


2.1 The league competition is open to any Rugby Football Club currently affiliated to the DRFU.

2.2 All clubs must adhere to the Policies of the Devon RFU and the RFU. Any club found guilty, by the CB Discipline Committee of breaching these Policies, may be deducted league points.

2.3 An entry fee will be payable by each club, the amount of which to be decided by the Devon RFU Junior Committee at the AGM each season. The fee to cover the cost of administration, trophies, medals, etc. 


3.1 To play in the league, a player must be under SIXTEEN years of age on the 1 September of the year in which the season commences.

3.2 The England RFU Age Grade regulations permit a player to play UP one age grade provided they have written permission from their parent or guardian to do so. In addition, the coach must assess that they are physically and emotionally able to play up one age grade, and have the skills and abilities to play at the higher age grade. Permission forms must be lodged with the Competition Administrator prior to the start of the game and be available for inspection by the opposition at each game the player plays in.

3.3 Players must be current members of the RFC they are playing for and must be registered on the RFU GMS, Game Management System for that Club, as well as with the league administrator. It is recommended that clubs register any/all of their Under 15 Squad, subject to 3.2 above, with the league administrator at the start of the season.

3.4 Players may transfer after the start of the season with the permission of the Competition Sub-Committee in advance of the move. This permission will need to be supported with written support from both Junior Club Chairman in line with the Devon RFU Transfer policy. A transfer will be considered by the Competition Sub Committee on individual merit, consideration will be given to house moves out of Clubs catchment areas.

3.5 Players who are new to the game, and are not previously registered with the England RFU as an active player, can be registered by a club with the RFU prior to 1st March in that season. Once registered, they can play in the league competition.

3.6 For the purposes of these rules, players that transfer from any club in Cornwall, Somerset or Dorset & Wilts constituent bodies, will be treated as if they played for a club affiliated to Devon.

3.7 Players that transfer from elsewhere in England, or transfer from another RFU, will be treated as “new” players as per 3.5 above.

3.8 Players are allowed to play down an Age Grade with the prior approval of the Devon RFU Player Dispensation Committee in line with the England RFU Regulations and guidelines. This application must be submitted by the Junior Club Chairman or Secretary.


4.1 Fixtures in the leagues shall be arranged in advance by the administrator and must be played on the dates given. In the event that a game is cancelled for any “eligible” reason, clubs must make every effort to re-schedule the match at the next available weekend. League matches will take priority over friendly matches. The fixtures will appear in the Devon RFU Handbook.

4.2 Matches will be 35 minutes each way. All matches will be played in accordance with the International Rugby Board (IRB) rules and regulations and England RFU regulations

4.3 No Age Grade player is permitted to play any additional time in a match.

4.4 In the event of a clash of colours, and/or at the request of the referee, it will be the HOME TEAM’S responsibility to change strip

4.5 If the points differential in any match reaches 50, the referee will consult with the coaches about continuing the match. It is recommended that the match continues with the team in the lead making substitutions to allow new or less experienced players to play, or the players are swapped between teams to even out the play. In any event, the maximum points differential that will be awarded to any team is 50.


For the purposes of section 5 of these Regulations:

A club may register more than 23 players, but can only have 23 named players on the day, with other registered squad members being available to play for the opposition (insert – if they wish).

A Team shall be defined as the number of registered players on the pitch at any point during the match not to be greater than 15 or less than 12 at the start of the game.

5.1 Match day squads for League matches can comprise up to 23 players.

5.2 In order for a match to proceed, under these regulations, both teams must start with at least 12 of their own registered playing squad.

5.3 Where a RFC has a small squad, and experiences team raising difficulties on a match day, it may borrow up to 5 players from their match day opponents, subject to 5.2 above.

5.4 It is expected that clubs will co-operate with their opponents in the loaning of players, to ensure that the maximum number of players are involved on match days, but players cannot be forced to play for opponents. Under age players must not be loaned, under any circumstances.

5.5 If players refuse to play for their opponents, which is their prerogative the match will be played with equal numbers on each team (subject to 5.2 above). Teams may have any number in their squads (subject to 5.1 and 5.2) with rolling substitutions being allowed at all times. Should a team be reduced to less than 12 through injury the match will be forfeited and treated as un-played and the points awarded as per 9.5.

Reduced number teams will line up with the following:

14 a side – no number 8

13 a side – no flankers (6 & 7)

12 a side – No back row

5.6 In the event that a loaned players receives a red card, the team that he is playing for will be deducted a league point, as per 6.2 below.

5.7 In all league matches, both teams will have the same number of players on the field of play at all times, except: where a player is temporarily suspended (‘Yellow Card’); or dismissed by the referee (‘Red Card’).

5.8 Each team in the competition should endeavour to have suitably trained and experienced front-row players and replacements. In a squad of 23 players, at least one player must be able to play at Loose Head and Tight Head Prop, and one player must be able to play at Hooker. If, for reasons beyond a team’s control there are no front row replacements available during a match, the referee will order non-contested scrums.

5.9 If a team does not have a suitably trained and experienced front row for the start of an arranged match, the match maybe be treated as an unplayed match (Section 9.5). The match will continue as a league match with uncontested scrums. The team or teams without sufficient front row players will submit a reason to the League Administrator within 48 hours of the game finishing so that the Sub Committee can rule if the game will be treated as a friendly or league game. This decision will be notified to the club within two weeks of the match being played.

5.10 The Sub-Committee recognises that Clubs don’t have players in the second phase of the league season and will permit a team to compete with no recognised front row for league games in the bottom level with prior permission. If a team progresses to the final they will be expected to start the match with a recognised front row. The league games are viewed as an opportunity to train a front row.


6.1 In all of the league competitions, pre-Christmas and post Christmas, points will be awarded on the following basis:

Win = 4 points: Draw = 2 points: Loss = 1 point

Bonus points will be awarded as follows:

1 point on scoring four tries in a game. (*)

1 point if the losing margin is 15 points or less. (*)

(*) It will be possible to accumulate both of these bonus points, even for a losing side.

6.2 A league point will be deducted for each red card issued to any player in all league matches. (Any subsequent Devon Disciplinary Panel punishment to be in addition to this one point deduction)

6.3 In determining league positions, the teams will be placed in order according to those with the most league points. Where there is a tie, points difference will take effect. However, only league games between those sides tied on league points will be counted.

6.4 The winner of the finals will be decided in the following manner:

  1. Team which has scored the most points in the match;

  2. Team which has scored the most tries in the match;

  3. Team which has scored the most converted tries in the match;

If all are equal, the Trophy shall be shared.


7.1 Matches played in the competition will be officiated by suitably qualified referees, appointed by the Devon Rugby Referees' Society or Plymouth Rugby Referees Society.

7.2 If either Referees' Society notifies a home club that no Society referee is available, the club can make application to the League Administrator for a referee to be appointed in the following order:

Member of a referee society from another CB

ELRA qualified club referee, from another RFC, or

ELRA qualified referee from within either participating club, where that referee is independent of the age group teams playing.

7.3 It shall be the responsibility of the home side to confirm match day arrangements with the appointed referee, by the Wednesday immediately preceding the match, or as soon as the appointment is made if later. Failure to do so, and therefore no referee turning up, will be treated as an unplayed match in accordance with Section 9.5.

7.4 Where Clubs cancel matches and they don’t notify the Referee the Society will charge that club for an attendance and any expenses occurred.

7.5 Each team should provide one competent person to act as touch judge acting, ideally not a player replacement, under the jurisdiction of the referee. Unless they are appointed as Assistant Referees, touch judges cannot signal offences or foul play, but may be consulted by the referee in appropriate circumstances.

7.6 Where games are postponed or arranged for another date the Devon Referee Society appointments Secretaries must be contacted in advance to allow them time to arrange for an appointment to be made. At least one weeks’ notice is the absolute minimum that will be accepted.


8.1 It is the responsibility of the Coach and Team Manager for each team entered into the leagues to comply with the administrative arrangements stipulated by the League administrator on behalf of the League Cub Committee.

8.2 It is the responsibility of the home team to provide the match result sheet for both teams which must be completed and handed to the referee no later than 30 minutes prior to the kick off. This will contain the names and RFU registration numbers of the players in the squad for that match. The first names and surnames used must be those under which the player is registered on the RFU GMS, Game Management System.

8.3 Each coach or team manager must ensure they have RFU registration cards, containing a recent picture of the player, for each player shown on the team sheet. These registration cards must be made available to the opposition to verify the eligibility of players.

8.4 Once the two coaches or team managers are both satisfied as to the eligibility of all the players, the team sheets will be handed to the referee.

8.5 It is the responsibility of both sides to inform the referee before the game which if any players have been loaned. It is the responsibility of the home side to inform, by way of the match result sheet, when a RFC has loaned its opponents any players, and if any player, from either side, has received a Red card.

8.6 At the conclusion of the match, or as soon as possible afterwards, the referee will enter the final score and sign the match result sheet. It is the responsibility of the home side to post/email the sheet to the League Administrator to arrive no later than the Wednesday immediately following the match.

8.7 It is also the responsibility of the home side to either text or email the result of the match to the administrator on the day evening of the game.

8.8 Late submissions of results on the day by text/e-mail and/or late submission of the full match result sheet by the Wednesday following the match will be referred to the Competition Sub-Committee by the League Administrator so that a decision on the number of points to be deducted can be made. First deduction will incur a ONE point deduction to a second occurrence a deduction of THREE points. Further occurrences’ will be stepped up in THREE point increments. No maximum points deduction will be placed on a team.


8.9 If ground or weather conditions prevent a match being played at the ground of the Club designated as the “home” side, every effort must be made to play the match either a) at the grounds of the designated “away” side, should that Club have a suitable pitch available or b) at a neutral venue (in which case the first named team will be deemed the “home side”.)

8.10 If ground or weather conditions prevent a match being played at the grounds of either Club, (or neutral venue) it may be re-scheduled by agreement between the two Clubs and the League Administrator. In the event of the Clubs being unable to agree to a revised date, the League Administrator may specify the date on which the match is to be played or the Sub Committee may award the match to one side or the other, dependant on the circumstances of the postponement. A rescheduled match must be played before the end of the Competition phase.

8.11 If a match is abandoned because of weather conditions (including bad light) when fifty or more minutes have been played, then the score at the moment of abandonment shall stand and be deemed the final score in the match. The Referee’s decision as to the necessity for abandonment and the number of minutes played at the moment of abandonment shall be final.

8.12 Matches that are postponed due to availability of players or other reasonable circumstances must notify the scheduled opponents before 12 Noon on the Saturday prior to the Sunday match by telephone/mobile voice communication. The club postponing the match are also required to notify the Referee and the Referee Appointments Secretary by voice communication and confirm that all have been cancelled with an e-mail to the League Administrator. If the match is being played on another day the same timescales will apply. Failure to adhere will result in the game being referred to the League Sub-Committee and maybe treated as a late submission of results (see 8.8). Matches will need to be re-arranged as per rule 8.10.


9.1 Coaches must endeavour to play the fixtures on the dates circulated by the League administrator.

9.2 If a match has to be postponed due to weather and pitch conditions, the home team must inform the visiting team, and referee as soon as that decision is made. This is particularly important during the post-Christmas period, when teams could be travelling much farther afield. The competition administrator will be notified by text or email by the home team within 24 hours of the decision to postpone the match.

9.3 It will be the responsibility of both clubs, through their Fixtures Secretaries, to agree on the date for which the game will be rescheduled – which will be the next available weekend when neither side has a league or cup match. In the event that the two clubs cannot agree, The League Administrator facilitates a date and if a date can't be agree then the Fisherman’s Cup Sub-Committee decides.

9.4 League fixtures take precedence over friendly matches. See Section 10.6, for clashes with knock-out cup games

9.5 Matches will not be postponed due to player County commitments, or other issues to do with squad availability, unless by mutual consent with their opponents, and only if an alternate date has already been agreed. If a team fails an obligation to play a match, the League Administrator must be notified by text or email within forty-eight hours of the scheduled game. The team that is deemed to be responsible for the match being unplayed will lose the game 15-0 and may be deducted up to 2 league points, depending on the circumstances by the League Sub-Committee. The non-offending side will receive 5 league points.

9.6 Any club which fails to fulfil 25% of its scheduled fixtures at any stage during the season could be removed from the competition and all records expunged by the League Sub-Committee after a review.


10.1 Any team which is proved to have fielded an ineligible player, whether by reason of being over or under the correct age, or because they are not registered, will be deducted five league points for every match in which the ineligible player(s) participated.

10.2 Coaches and Team Managers/Administrators are responsible for their own behaviour, and that of the parents, guardians and supporters of their team. The standard of behaviour expected is that laid out in the RFU Codes of Conduct. Where the conduct of an individual or group of people falls below that standard, that individual or group may be liable for sanctions to be imposed by the Devon RFU.

10.3 Each team should have a dedicated First Aider, who may also be a coach. The First Aider shall be the only person permitted to enter the field of play during the match. Clubs are required to have a person or persons identified and visible on match days.

10.4 Home teams must ensure that pitches are surrounded by a barrier, at least two metres from the touchline, and around the whole pitch, behind which all Coaches, Replacements and non-participating people must remain at all times.

10.5 A technical area maybe provided which should be clearly marked, where the replacements and coaches will be allowed.


11.1 A team may appeal regarding the decision of the league administrator in relation to the administration of that league.

11.2 An appeal must be made in writing, and come from either of the Junior Section Chairman or Secretary supported by the Club Chairman where possible and sent to the Devon Junior Section Chairman (as shown in the Devon Handbook).

11.3 Appeals will not be accepted by the Devon RFU Competitions Sub-Committee from coaches, parents or guardians of players.

11.4 An appeal must be made within seventy-two hours of the event/decision about which the appeal is being made.

11.5 The Secretary of the Devon RFU Competitions Sub-Committee will arrange for the appeal to be heard in accordance with the procedures of the sub-committee. Members of the Devon RFU who have a conflict of interest for any reason will declare such and not be involved in the appeal hearing.

11.6 The parties will be informed in writing by the Secretary of the Devon RFU Competitions Sub-Committee once the hearing has been completed.


Where not covered separately the rules of the Devon Senior Cup will apply, including financial arrangements.


The Fisherman’s Cup Sub Committee will review these rules annually.